COPYRIGHT, 1903,

BY
WEST PUBLISHING COMPANY.

COURTS REPORTED DURING THE PERIOD COVERED BY THIS VOLUME.

ASSOCIATE JUDGES.
WOODFIN D. ROBINSON.

JAMES B. BLACK.
WILLIAM J. HENLEY.

DANIEL W. COMSTOCK.
ULRIC Z. WILEY.

Division No. 1.

JAMES B. BLACK, PRESIDING JUDGE.

ASSOCIATE JUDGES.
WOODFIN D. ROBINSON.

WILLIAM J. HENLEY.

Division No. 2.

FRANK S. ROBY, CHIEF JUDGE.

ASSOCIATE JUDGES.
DANIEL W. COMSTOCK.

ULRIC Z. WILEY.

MASSACHUSETTS-Supreme Judicial Court.

OLIVER WENDELL HOLMES, CHIEF JUSTICE.
MARCUS P. KNOWLTON, CHIEF JUSTICE.5

ASSOCIATE JUSTICES.
MARCUS P. KNOWLTON. 5

JAMES M. BARKER.
JAMES M. MORTON.

JOHN WILKES HAMMOND.
JOHN LATHROP.

WILLIAM CALEB LORING.
HENRY K. BRALEY.6

1 Ceased to be Chief Justice June 2, 1902.
? Became Chief Justice June 2, 1902.
3 Term began June 2, 1902.

4 Appointed to Supreme Court of the United States December 8, 1902.

5 Became Chief Justice January 12, 1903.

6 Term began January 12, 1903. (ili)

Kepul JIYE! Jil

NEW YORK-Court of Appeals.

ALTOX B. PARKER, CHIEF JUDGE.

A8-OCIATE JI'DES,
JONIX (. GRAY.

(ELORA E MARTIN DINIS O'BRIX

IRVING. 1.1.X.X.
EDWARD T. 15.AIKTLETT

EDGIR CULLIN
ALBERT IIAIGIIT.

WILLIAM E. WERST.R.